Liszt: Cantatas and Hymns
Hungaroton's collection of six or seven cantatas and hymns is a bit of a mixed bag.
The first item based on Saint Francis of Assisi's Canticle of the Sun / Canticle of Creatures might have been finer, but baritone György Melis does not have an attractive sound, and is featured across most of the 15 minutes, with only a few outbursts from the male chorus.
The Bells of Strasbourg Cathedral is much more convincing. The two parts, Excelsior! and The Bells, are quite epic in nature, one which strikes an ancient and mighty quality, complete with chimes and chanting men's chorus. The orchestra and chorus also have meatier roles, dividing up the time between ensemble, chorus, and soloists intelligently, with the soloists of firmer vocal mettle. I will say, having these Hungarian performers sing in English is not especially idiomatic to my English-speaking ears, but the attempt is well appreciated nonetheless.
For a mostly choral/orchestral program, having György Melis return as a soloist with piano accompaniment only in the Saint Christopher Legend did not thrill me over its 10 minutes, even if the women's choir sings nicely opposite the tremulous Hungarian baritone, who seems to handle the stronger martial atmosphere somewhat better here. As with many of Liszt's vocal lied, the piano is given a substantial role in the action of the music, and the composer is even more apt to use chromaticisms in the song.
The Saint Cecilia Legend grasps me better, no doubt attributed to having the Patron Saint of Music as the subject of the piece. St. Cecilia is often portrayed with an organ or harp at hand, so I was surprised neither appeared in this 14-minute orchestral song with chorus, although the pipe organ does rear its hear ferociously in the final moments. Instead, mezzo-soprano Lívia Budai beautifully sets a mysterious and powerful musical scene in French, nearly having all of the runtime to herself.
Following comes an Antiphon for the Feast Day of Saint Cecilia, entitled Cantatibus Organis, and here is where the listener is given a hardy pipe organ role opposite full chorus. Mezzo-soprano Klára Takács follows the previous mezzo just as exquisitely, making for a fine pairing of St. Cecilia pieces. This one is also the shortest on the program, perhaps giving into the Hymn portion of the title.
The final number on the program, Hymne de L'enfant a Son Reveil, is sung by female chorus, backed by pipe organ and harp only. This is perhaps the most straightforward choral piece across the seven tracks, with a strophic feeling of structure with some a cappella bits thrown in. All said, Hungaroton offers a nice variety of rare vocal and choral music from Liszt.
What strikes me most across these pieces, is Liszt's settings of texts from various languages. The listener is treated to songs set in English, German, French, Italian, and Latin, a wide variety for the Hungarian Radio and Television Chorus to tackle. The choral ensemble does a nice job of it, although if their English is any indication, don't expect the tidiest of pronunciations.
These performances are gathered from Hungaroton's Liszt Choral Works I released in 1968, where Miklós Szabó leads the final Hymne and Saint Christopher Legend. The rest come from Liszt Choral Works V in 1977 with János Ferencsik conducting. Both are sonically impressive for their age, and the Budapest Symphony Orchestra sounds pretty darn good too.
While Franz Liszt might be best known for his solo piano and orchestral music, I am continually amazed by the work he put into the genres of voice and chorus, with and without orchestra. This particular program is hit and miss, but I find that to be the case within any genre Liszt composed, even his most renowned.
Works
Cantico del Sol di San Francesco d'Assisi, S. 4/2
Bells of Strasbourg Cathedral, S. 6
Sankt Christoph. Legend, S. 47
Sankt Cecile. Legend, S. 5/2a
Cantatibus Organis, S. 7
Hymne de l'enfant á son réveil, S. 19/4
Soloists
Éva Andor, soprano
Lívia Budai, mezzo-soprano
Klára Takács, mezzo-soprano
György Melis, baritone
Sándor Sólyom-Nagy, baritone
György Miklós, piano (S. 47)
Hédi Lubik, harp (S. 19 & 47)
Gábor Lehotka, organ (S. 19 & 47)
Sándor Margittay, organ
Ensembles
Győr Girl's Choir (S. 19 & 47)
Miklós Szabó, conductor (S. 19 & 47)
Hungarian Radio and Television Chorus
Budapest Symphony Orchestra
János Ferencsik, conductor
Label: Hungaroton
Year: 2001
Total Timing: 70.01
No, I am not agog with Liszt's choral music thus far, but I think his Hungarian Coronation Mass does better than many others. I do think the work could grow on me over time too, although I recognize the Mass is unbalanced musically.
I generally find this later Hungaroton recording more put together vocally and orchestrally compared to the earlier one with Ferencsik conducting on DGG. That 1960s performance, though, has its attributes too.
Find more Liszt recordings HERE!

Comments
Post a Comment