Stanford: Symphony 6
The scherzo-like opening of First Irish Rhapsody is a lot of fun, with a dreamy harp role making a segue to the slower, Romantic middle portion. To my ears, this central area becomes overly syrupy, mainly due to the presence of the well-known Londonderry Air. When the minor-keyed opening Scherzo is eventually overlaid with Danny Boy, I am not quite sure what to think, other than the work lays akin to a Holst Military Band Suite or the Vaughan Williams Folk Song Suite, both wonderful works which historically follow in Stanford's footsteps.
At least Stanford avoids any expected hoary sentimentality from the familiar strains of Emer's Farewell to Cuchullin, although it is a close call from my viewpoint. Vernon Handley aids in this aspect, for he moves along Irish Rhapsody no. 1 purposefully, never allowing the music to settle too comfortably or wallow in nostalgic golden-touched hues.
I really enjoy the robust and jolly first movement of Stanford's Symphony no. 6 in E-flat Major. It is filled with ever-moving delights, ones which often remind me as a mix of Richard Strauss and Felix Mendelssohn. Here is uplifting music I could put on repeat with little in the way of regrets on my part. An English Horn solo makes up much of the second movement's beginning, evoking a becalmed pastoral note opposite the firmer musical setting of the first movement. At nearly 13 minutes in length, this section goes on a mite too long, but it is music which is easy to luxuriate in, this time with regrets.
A teensy-weensy three-minute Scherzo is more transitional than a standalone third movement. I daresay, some more time with this Scherzo might be preferred over what we get from the final movement, one which arrives without break from the preceding movement. Stanford seems to sound out at his most 'British' in concluding movements, especially when attempting a march, as he does here. While the joy found in the opening of the Sixth Symphony returns in this last movement amidst small episodes of musical turmoil, the fourth movement never truly sticks its landing as an event. Let's just say there is more stiff pomp and lyrical musings than dynamic electricity, coming alongside a delicate ending.
I do enjoy Vernon Handley's driven account of Symphony no. 6, although some may enjoy the spaciousness afforded by David Lloyd-Jones on Naxos. Certainly the Ulster Orchestra enjoy the exploration of Stanford's symphonies throughout the Chandos series, here with a slightly watery acoustic.
Works
Symphony 6 in E-flat Major, op. 94 (36.06)
Irish Rhapsody 6 in D minor, op. 78 (13.37)
Performers
Ulster Orchestra
Vernon Handley, conductor
Label: Chandos
Year: 1988
Total Timing: 49.50
Symphony 6 in E-flat Major, op. 94 (36.06)
Irish Rhapsody 6 in D minor, op. 78 (13.37)
Performers
Ulster Orchestra
Vernon Handley, conductor
Label: Chandos
Year: 1988
Total Timing: 49.50
I don't think Stanford's Sixth Symphony will be a favorite of his seven outings, but there are many more positive elements to the work than niggling attributes.
Certainly hearing the first of the composer's Irish Rhapsodies is a must hear. Handley does so without overdoing the sentimentality as much as he can, which I appreciate.
Find more Stanford recordings HERE!


Comments
Post a Comment