I like John Rutter and his music. Some find the composer's musical brand treacly and sing-songy, but this isn't a problem for me. In many cases, Rutter's original carols and arrangements for Christmas are some of my favorites, and unapologetically so.
That said, I mostly associate Rutter's music with choir, with a few instrumental works at the periphery. Here, three tracks add chorus, but the rest of the 13 items are pure brass band.
In another one of my recent Christmas recordings posts, I mentioned my aversion to the British brass band sound, which we have here. The tight, insistent vibrato, with cornets in the lead, just aren't to my listening tastes. I can appreciate the fine ensemble work and treacherous literature brass bands often tackle with great virtuosity, but the sound bothers me nonetheless.
And I guess that is my problem here. I know most of these songs from John Rutter, and I miss the singing. As I was listening, I was yearning to take out my two Cambridge Singers Christmas recordings led by the composer.
Not that there is anything bad here; far from it. The Black Dyke Band is synonymous with high standards of playing, and they apply it adroitly to Rutter's music. The Sheffield Chorus, though, sounds off on this recording day, where I have heard better from them on other recordings.
Who is this for then? If you don't like singing, this could be your 'in' to John Rutter's music. The composer knows how to churn out a satisfying melody, and his lush harmonies bear remarkably good feelings, especially upon the yuletide.
Listen on YouTube
Performers
Sheffield Philharmonic Chorus
Black Dyke Band
Darius Battiwala, conductor
Nicholas Childs, conductor
Label: Naxos
Year: 2024
Total Timing: 60.04
I love the music of John Rutter, I just don't like this recording.
I will not hide my dislike for the British brass band sound, but more than that, I simply miss the singing meant to go with this music.
Yet, I also realize, this could be great for someone else to explore Rutter's music.
No comments:
Post a Comment