Put on by Yoel Levi at Atlanta.I have mentioned before I think Yoel Levi was under-appreciated at Atlanta.
And this isn't a particularly bad set of overtures, but they can hardly stand up to a treasure-trove of recordings.
Sir Neville covered 3CDs of Rossini overtures, and I think Naxos stopped at four discs. So, not only do you get the 'hits', but also some lesser-known ones too.
Plus, there are the Italians. Abbado, Chailly, Giulini, Muti, and Toscanini to name a few. These fellows have a way with Rossini's music which few others can replicate.
But, if you are looking for a few overtures, and can't find Fritz Reiner or the like, this will do OK, silly cover art and all!
Review from 2006
In
textbooks, Gioacchino Rossini was a composer of the Romantic Era, but
by all accounts, the majority of his music was composed in the Classical
Era (his final opera, William Tell, was written in 1829) and Rossini
retired without composing until his death in 1868. His music exhibits
the light and balanced musical structure of the Classical Era, but his
advanced orchestrations and harmonies show their roots in the Romantic
Era, all evident in the seven popular opera overtures represented in
this disk.
The 11-minute William Tell overture shows Rossini's
mature and well-developed style. The broad strokes of awakening dawn
into a wild thunderstorm, complete with small raindrops before the
actual storm, is brilliant. The pastoral landscape smiles with the
famous English horn solo, and the military homecoming is announced by
the famous trumpet call. So many wonderful motives, orchestrated
colorfully and with great variety. Also well-known, is the overture to
the Thieving Magpie. Despite the serious plot, the music is
lighthearted. The opening drum-roll suggests a military presence and
goes right into a stuffy march, full of pompous grandeur. The
second-half of the 9-minute overture moves at a swifter pace and the
famous oboe solo almost sounds sneaky with its ambiguous staccato
movement. The 7-minute overture to The Italian Girl in Algiers is also
fairly well known, and one of Rossini's earlier overtures, showing some
more formulaic classicism. The very easy-going, and quiet, harmonic
sequence of the opening, along with a surprise loud chord, is evident of
Classicism in Haydn's era. But the later fast section, heralds the
more mature style of Rossini, with whirlwind woodwinds, a humorous
piccolo melody, and various other delightful orchestral colorings. Also
included is the famous Barber of Seville, the epitome of Rossini's
mature style. Chock full o' catchy melodies, whimsical orchestral
settings, and natural, dramatic build-ups, this 7-minute overture ranks
as the best for good reason.
Not so well known to the general
public are the overtures to Semiramide, The Silken Ladder, and Tancredi.
Perhaps it is because they are a bit more formulaic, but moreso,
probably because they are not the showstoppers that the previously
described overtures are. Semiramide, 11 minutes, opens with a gently
lilting section for horns; eventually a martial and bubbly section
enters with classical harmonic treatments and occasional Romantic
suprises. The Silken Ladder may not overwhelm the listeners in
decibels, but it certainly does in charm. After a slow wind-centered
introduction, a romp with fluttering winds and an easy-sounding theme
give the 6-minute overture grace and charm. In the same vein, the
6-minute Tancredi overture has a jumpy motive with accents in the winds.
Despite popularity, it is Rossini who reinforced the "Italian" sound
in the opera world, setting up the popularity of Verdi, a man who had
such a deep respect for his older master Rossini.
Yoel Levi and
the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra provide a vivid and colorful portrayal of
Rossini's overtures. This does not have the delicate lightness of a
period or chamber performance, but that is OK if you are looking for a
full Romantic sound quality. Levi gives a buoyant and bubbling modern
sound that is full and fun, never unduly heavy or plodding, and
certainly not out of perspective. This is certainly a demonstration
class CD, one that hits the ball right down the middle of the road; not
too fast and not too slow. Every voice of the orchestra is extremely
clear, and the Telarc sound is spacious, giving the ensemble presence.
The playing time is a little slim and could have included one or two
more overtures, but this is a prime Rossini performance.
Listen on YouTube
Works
William Tell (11.13)
Thieving Magpie (9.33)
Italian in Algiers (7.40)
Semiramide (11.43)
Silken Ladder (5.56)
Tancredi (5.53)
Barber of Seville (7.13)
Performers
Atlanta Symphony Orchestra
Yoel Levi, conductor
Label: Telarc
Year: 1994
Total Timing: 59.46
As I was writing up a reflection of this recording, I realized, you can do better.
Not that this is a bad recording, far, far from it. The mere timings of these overtures show Atlanta and Levi are peppily forward moving with a very full sound.
Yet, a sub-50 minute runtime and plenty to offer without this, is plenty of reason to call The Kraken.
Sure you could do much, much worse, but why when you can have the best?
Find more Rossini recordings HERE!
No comments:
Post a Comment